Skip to content
  • Young in the Mountains Young in the Mountains
  • Shop
    • In stock : ships soon
    • Custom made : ships within 7 weeks
    • Gem library : ships within 7 weeks
  • process
    • Artistry
    • Sourcing
  • story
    • About us
    • Our mission
    • Ethics
Young in the Mountains Young in the Mountains
  • Book Appointment
  • Log in
  • 0 Cart (0 items)
ALL POSTS

The Age-Old Debate: Which is More Rare, Diamonds or Sapphires?

We pride ourselves on the most unique and ethical diamonds & Montana sapphries!

The Age-Old Debate: Which is More Rare, Diamonds or Sapphires?

When it comes to precious gemstones, few are as highly sought after as diamonds and sapphires. Both are known for their beauty, durability, and rarity, but the diamond tends to be the most popular and are touted as rare.  But is it true? are diamonds more rare then sapphires or is it the other way around? 

Gemstone enthusiasts have debated this question for years. 

Today, we're exploring the factors determining gemstone rarity to settle this argument once and for all. 

Join us as we delve into the world of precious gemstones and uncover the truth behind the rarity of sapphires and diamonds.

Understanding Rarity in Gemstones

Rarity is a significant factor in determining the value and price of gemstones like diamonds and sapphires. 

It refers to how scarce a gemstone is and how difficult it is to find, mine, and process. Generally speaking, the rarer a gemstone, the more expensive it is.

However, it is not the only factor influencing the value and price of gemstones.

Other factors include beauty, durability, demand, and market conditions. For example, a rare but not very attractive or durable gemstone may not be valuable or expensive. On the other hand, a common gemstone that's beautiful or durable may be very valuable.

So, when comparing the value of rare gemstones like diamonds and sapphires, we look beyond their rarity in nature and at their quality, color, size, and shape. 

Rarity of Diamonds

Not all diamonds are equally rare or valuable. The most valuable diamonds are normally colorless with high clarity. 

Diamonds are graded according to the 4Cs (color, clarity, cut, and carat weight), a standardized system to evaluate their quality and value.

  • Colorless diamonds are graded on a scale from D (the most colorless) to Z (the most yellow or brown) – the less color, the rarer and more expensive. However, there are also "fancy colored diamonds", including pink, red, black, green, or blue stones, which are extremely rare and valuable.
  • Clarity refers to how clear a diamond is from any flaws that can affect its brilliance and sparkle. The clearer, the rarer and more expensive it is.
  • Cut refers to how well a diamond has been shaped and polished. It affects how well a diamond reflects light and creates fire (flashes of color) and scintillation (sparkle). The better the cut, the more beautiful and valuable.
  • Carat weight refers to how much a diamond weighs in metric carats (one carat equals 0.2 grams). 

Meet Some of the Rarest Diamonds

The Hope Diamond

The largest blue diamond in the world, originally 112 carats. However, after a sinister past, including gambling addiction, madness, murder, death, poverty, and the French Revolution, the ironically named "Hope" diamond is believed to be cursed. It's been recut several times to its now 45.52 carats and at display at the Smithsonian Institution.

The Cullinan

The largest rough diamond ever found, originally weighing 3,106.75 carats. It was discovered in South Africa in 1905 and presented to King Edward VII. The diamond was cut into 96 smaller stones and nine major ones, two of which are part of the British Crown Jewels.

The Pink Star

The most expensive diamond ever sold at an auction. It sold for $71.2 million in 2017. It is a 59.6-carat vivid pink diamond with an oval shape and an internally flawless clarity grade.

The Golden Jubilee

The world's largest faceted (flat surfaces arranged in a geometrical pattern) diamond, weighing 545.67 carats. It took two years to cut. The stone has a goldish, brown hue and was discovered in South Africa in 1985. In 1997, it was presented to the King of Thailand for his Golden Jubilee.

 

Rarity of Sapphires

Sapphires' rarity varies depending on the type and color of the stone. 

The most common sapphire color is blue, but they can also be pink, purple, yellow, green, orange, white, black, and even colorless.

The most valuable sapphires are vivid in color and have good transparency (allowing light to pass through). These sapphires are graded according to their: 

  • Hue (the basic color)
  • Saturation (the intensity or purity of the color)
  • Tone (the lightness or darkness of the color)
  • Cut (the shape and polish)
  • Clarity (the presence or absence of flaws or inclusions)
  • Carat weight (the size)
  • Origin (geographical source)
  • Treatment (the enhancement or alteration by heat or other methods)

The rarest and most expensive type of sapphire is called padparadscha, which has an orange-pink color that resembles a lotus flower. They command very high prices due to their scarcity and beauty.

Meet Some of the Rarest Sapphires

The Star of Adam 

A relatively new discovery, founded in 2016, it's the world's largest blue star sapphire, weighing 1,404.49 carats. It's privately owned and valued at $300 million.

The Black Star of Queensland

Discovered in the 1930s, this beauty was originally used as a doorstop before being discovered for what it really was. After being cut and polished, the stone weighed a whooping 733 carats. 

The Blue Belle of Asia

The most expensive sapphire ever sold at a public auction for $17.3 million in 2014. It is a 392.52-carat cushion-shaped Ceylon sapphire with an exceptional cornflower blue color and excellent transparency.

The Blue Giant of the Orient

A 486-carat blue sapphire that is the largest faceted sapphire in the world. Surrounded by mystery, the stone was discovered in Sri Lanka in 1907 and bought by an American collector, then disappeared from the public's eye for almost 100 years. It resurfaced in 2004 and was sold to an anonymous buyer for $1 million.

Comparing the Rarity between Diamonds and Sapphires

So, which gemstone is rarer: diamonds or sapphires? The answer depends on what kind of diamonds and sapphires we are comparing.

All diamonds vs. all sapphires, regardless of quality or color. 

Diamonds are rarer than sapphires, accounting for only 1% of global gemstone production by weight. 

High-quality diamonds vs. high-quality sapphires.

Sapphires may be rarer than diamonds because they have more color and quality variations. For example, a flawless D-color diamond may be more common than a flawless padparadscha sapphire.

Fancy-colored diamonds vs. fancy-colored sapphires.

Diamonds may be rarer than sapphires because they have fewer natural colors. For example, a pink diamond may be rarer than a pink sapphire.

Geologialy

Sapphires occur more rarely in the earth then diamonds, so if we are compaing based on origin, sapphires are truly the more rare stone! 

Therefore, the rarity of diamonds and sapphires depends on how we define and measure them. 

Both gemstones have unique characteristics and appeal that make them valuable and desirable. Our montana sapphires are sourced direct from USA miners making them the best choice if your comparing ethics of the gemstone.

Whether you prefer diamonds or sapphires for your next jewelry purchase, you can be sure that you are getting a precious and exquisite gemstone that will last for generations.

If you are in the market for a beautiful jewelry piece containing an ethically sourced gemstone of the highest quality, visit Young In The Mountains!

 

FACEBOOK
Share on Facebook
PINTEREST
Pin on Pinterest
EMAIL
Send email

More Posts

ALL POSTS
Some Like It Hot: Heat Treating Of Montana Sapphires

04/15/2025

Some Like It Hot: Heat Treating Of Montana Sapphires

READ MORE
The Ultimate Guide to Men's Rings: Width, fit, & style

04/15/2025

The Ultimate Guide to Men's Rings: Width, fit, & style

READ MORE
Elegance in Darkness: Black Diamond Engagement Rings

11/07/2023

Elegance in Darkness: Black Diamond Engagement Rings

READ MORE
The Beauty of Balance: Styling Tips for Diamond Stacking Bands

11/07/2023

The Beauty of Balance: Styling Tips for Diamond Stacking Bands

READ MORE

Invalid Password
Enter

Help

  • FAQs
  • Shipping
  • Warranty
  • Timelines
  • Resize & Repair
  • Terms Of Service

Education

  • Journal
  • Stacking Guide
  • Jewelry Care

    Illustration of brush in a cup for jewelry care

    Jewelry Care

    Diamonds, sapphires and gold are the traditional materials to wear as engagement or wedding jewelry because they are the most durable. Only these three materials are our recommendation for use as an engagement ring.

    Sunstones, emeralds, opals and inlay stones are beautiful accents, but should not be considered up for every day, forever wear in an engagement ring stack.  Forever is a long time, so choose wisely when considering a ring to be the everyday representation of your love. It’s a big decision to represent your love with fine jewelry, consider a versatile set that can we worn in all the different times and events in your life.

    All jewelry requires care and attention, so please realize just because a ring is chosen from our website and presented as a wedding ring, does not mean it's appropriate for everyday wear. The materials are very important. All jewelry should be taken off before bathing, swimming, yoga, applying lotions, working out, doing the dishes, etc.

    We recommend a simple pure gold band as the everyday forever wedding ring. Our inlay jewelry can be worn as the occasion permits. More information is explained in our FAQ PAGE.

  • Find Your Ring Size

    Not sure if your ring will fit with our ring crowns? Print our easy-to-use, sizing guide, specifically made to help you find the perfect signature ring crown that fits your existing engagement ring.

    DOWNLOAD OUR RING CROWN GUIDE

  • Heirloom Stones
  • Ring Crown PDF Try On
  • Ring Crown Physical Try On
  • Make A Confident Purchase

Find us

  • Contact Us
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Visit us

  • Retailers
  • Store Information
  • Book An Appointment

Company

  • Our story
  • Ethics
  • Gift cards
  • Customer stories

Connect with us

Get updates on special releases & sales

  • Copyright 2025 Young in the Mountains

Shopping Bag

sub total $0.00

Important Information

To ensure the success of your purchase, we require you to read the CONFIDENT DECISION & the FAQ page before placing your order.

Made To Order items ship in 6-8 weeks. Please understand that Available Now items ship within 3 business days. We ship EXPRESS when it's ready to ship, it is not, "same-day express shipping." Please read our SHIPPING DETAILS.

Please check the box that you understand the important details related to working with YITM.

Continue Shopping Go to checkout

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

Sentimental Information

We love hearing your stories! This helps us connect with you while we are crafting your piece. It makes you real to us. The power of jewelry is to connect us, to make us remember, and honor an experience. This beauty we create is not surface deep, our jewelry is here to add sentiment into our daily lives. Please, oh please, give us a few words about you, and your story. It will make our hearts full!

Skip this step and take me to checkout
back