Skip to content
  • Young in the Mountains Young in the Mountains
  • Shop
    • In stock : ships soon
    • Custom made : ships within 7 weeks
    • Gem library : ships within 7 weeks
  • process
    • Artistry
    • Sourcing
  • story
    • About us
    • Our mission
    • Ethics
Young in the Mountains Young in the Mountains
  • Book Appointment
  • Log in
  • 0 Cart (0 items)
ALL POSTS

The ultimate guide to spotting the difference between costume jewelry and fine jewelry

We'll explore how adding luxury pieces can elevate your investment strategy and help you diversify your assets with style.

The ultimate guide to spotting the difference between costume jewelry and fine jewelry

When it comes to jewelry, there are two distinct categories: costume jewelry and fine jewelry. Each has unique characteristics, making it important to understand the difference before purchasing your select piece.

What is costume jewelry?

Costume jewelry is made to look like fine jewelry but is not made of precious metals or stones. It is usually made of cheaper metals and materials, such as brass, bronze, copper, glass, plastic, and synthetic stones. 

Costume jewelry is often worn for fashion purposes and is not intended to be a permanent piece in a collection. 

What is fine jewelry?

Fine jewelry is made from more expensive materials and is designed to last a lifetime. It is also important to note that fine jewelry is often made with more attention to detail and has a higher quality finish than costume jewelry.


Costume jewelry vs. fine jewelry.

Costume jewelry and fine jewelry each have benefits that can make them the right choice for different occasions. 

Pros of costume jewelry

  • Cheaper price tag
  • Wide variety of styles and designs
  • Easily replaceable
  • Easier to accessorize with different outfits

Cons of costume jewelry

  • Low-quality materials
  • Prone to discoloration and tarnishing
  • Easily broken or cracked
  • May cause skin irritation
  • Can look like fine jewelry, possibly leading to scams
  •  not sourced or manufactured in responsible ways. 

Pros of fine jewelry

  • High-quality materials
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Can be passed down through generations
  • Timeless style
  • Can be used as an investment
  • Due to higher material costs, more tracking is available on materials meaning more ethical sourcing. 

Cons of fine jewelry

  • More expensive price tag
  • Not as easily accessible
  • May require special cleaning and maintenance
  • May not be as fashionable as costume jewelry

Differences in materials and quality

There are vast differences in costume and fine jewelry's materials and quality. Costume jewelry is generally made from lower-quality materials, such as metals plated with a thin layer of gold or silver or made from synthetic gemstones. 

Fine jewelry is made from high-quality materials, such as solid gold or silver, and natural gemstones. 


Differences in design and craftsmanship

Costume jewelry is designed to be worn for a shorter time and is not as well made as fine jewelry. When it comes to design, costume jewelry tends to be flashier and more over-the-top. It is also mass-produced.

Fine jewelry is designed to last a lifetime, and the craftsmanship quality is much higher than costume jewelry. It is handmade by skilled artisans and is generally more understated and timeless. 


Differences in price and value

Fine jewelry is made from higher-quality materials and is typically more expensive than costume jewelry. 

Fine jewelry is the better option if you are looking for something that will last a lifetime. 

Choosing between costume jewelry vs. fine jewelry

If you're considering adding some new jewelry to your collection, you may be wondering whether to go for costume jewelry or fine jewelry. Here's a quick guide to help you decide which is right for you.

Materials

What materials do you prefer - plastic or glass used in less expensive fashion jewelry or luxury metals used in high-end fine jewelry? Do you want materials sourced in an ethical way that can be traced and verified? Fine jewelry is for you. 

Durability

How long do you want your jewelry to last? Costume jewelry is often less durable than fine jewelry and may not withstand everyday wear and tear. Fine jewelry will be the better option if you're looking for something that will last for many years.

If you are looking for ethical fine jewelry, Young In The Mountains is the jeweler for you! 

Find your special piece today.
FACEBOOK
Share on Facebook
PINTEREST
Pin on Pinterest
EMAIL
Send email

More Posts

ALL POSTS
Some Like It Hot: Heat Treating Of Montana Sapphires

04/15/2025

Some Like It Hot: Heat Treating Of Montana Sapphires

READ MORE
The Ultimate Guide to Men's Rings: Width, fit, & style

04/15/2025

The Ultimate Guide to Men's Rings: Width, fit, & style

READ MORE
Elegance in Darkness: Black Diamond Engagement Rings

11/07/2023

Elegance in Darkness: Black Diamond Engagement Rings

READ MORE
The Beauty of Balance: Styling Tips for Diamond Stacking Bands

11/07/2023

The Beauty of Balance: Styling Tips for Diamond Stacking Bands

READ MORE

Invalid Password
Enter

Help

  • FAQs
  • Shipping
  • Warranty
  • Timelines
  • Resize & Repair
  • Terms Of Service

Education

  • Journal
  • Stacking Guide
  • Jewelry Care

    Illustration of brush in a cup for jewelry care

    Jewelry Care

    Diamonds, sapphires and gold are the traditional materials to wear as engagement or wedding jewelry because they are the most durable. Only these three materials are our recommendation for use as an engagement ring.

    Sunstones, emeralds, opals and inlay stones are beautiful accents, but should not be considered up for every day, forever wear in an engagement ring stack.  Forever is a long time, so choose wisely when considering a ring to be the everyday representation of your love. It’s a big decision to represent your love with fine jewelry, consider a versatile set that can we worn in all the different times and events in your life.

    All jewelry requires care and attention, so please realize just because a ring is chosen from our website and presented as a wedding ring, does not mean it's appropriate for everyday wear. The materials are very important. All jewelry should be taken off before bathing, swimming, yoga, applying lotions, working out, doing the dishes, etc.

    We recommend a simple pure gold band as the everyday forever wedding ring. Our inlay jewelry can be worn as the occasion permits. More information is explained in our FAQ PAGE.

  • Find Your Ring Size

    Not sure if your ring will fit with our ring crowns? Print our easy-to-use, sizing guide, specifically made to help you find the perfect signature ring crown that fits your existing engagement ring.

    DOWNLOAD OUR RING CROWN GUIDE

  • Heirloom Stones
  • Ring Crown PDF Try On
  • Ring Crown Physical Try On
  • Make A Confident Purchase

Find us

  • Contact Us
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest

Visit us

  • Retailers
  • Store Information
  • Book An Appointment

Company

  • Our story
  • Ethics
  • Gift cards
  • Customer stories

Connect with us

Get updates on special releases & sales

  • Copyright 2025 Young in the Mountains

Shopping Bag

sub total $0.00

Important Information

To ensure the success of your purchase, we require you to read the CONFIDENT DECISION & the FAQ page before placing your order.

Made To Order items ship in 6-8 weeks. Please understand that Available Now items ship within 3 business days. We ship EXPRESS when it's ready to ship, it is not, "same-day express shipping." Please read our SHIPPING DETAILS.

Please check the box that you understand the important details related to working with YITM.

Continue Shopping Go to checkout

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

Sentimental Information

We love hearing your stories! This helps us connect with you while we are crafting your piece. It makes you real to us. The power of jewelry is to connect us, to make us remember, and honor an experience. This beauty we create is not surface deep, our jewelry is here to add sentiment into our daily lives. Please, oh please, give us a few words about you, and your story. It will make our hearts full!

Skip this step and take me to checkout
back